POWERED BY THE GARRETT TEAM of NJ REALTY PROS | 732-580-4712

Aerial view of 1232 Bay Avenue, Toms River, NJ with the parcel outlined

1232 Bay Avenue

Toms River, NJResidential

Shelter Cove
3
Beds
1
Baths
1976
Year Built
0.251 ac
Lot Size
Flood ZoneZone X

Minimal flood risk

Minimal flood hazard.

Source: FEMA National Flood Hazard Layer. Verify with your insurer.

Tax & Assessment

Total Assessed Value
$299,600
Land Value
$115,000
Improvement Value
$184,600
Annual Property Tax
$5,456
Property Class
Residential

Neighborhood

$384,000
Median home value
$104,695
Median household income
99%
Owner-occupied

Source: U.S. Census Bureau, American Community Survey (5-year), for this home's census tract.

Nearby Schools

  • Toms River High School East
    High School · Toms River
    0.7 mi
  • East Dover Elementary School
    Elementary · Toms River
    1.0 mi
  • Island Heights Elementary School
    Elementary · Island Heights
    2.0 mi
  • Cedar Grove Elementary School
    Elementary · Toms River
    2.1 mi
  • Washington Street Elementary School
    Elementary · Toms River
    2.4 mi

Nearest public schools by distance. Source: NCES (U.S. Dept. of Education). Confirm attendance zones with the school district.

Recent Sales in Shelter Cove

  • 2400 Stanley Drive, Toms River, Nj 08753
    Sold May 2026 · 3 bd · 2 ba · 1,991 sq ft
    $530,000
  • 6 Cove Road, Toms River, Nj 08753
    Sold May 2026 · 5 bd · 3 ba · 3,052 sq ft
    $1,689,000
  • 30 Wilkins Road, Toms River, Nj 08753
    Sold May 2026 · 4 bd · 3 ba · 3,633 sq ft
    $1,899,000
  • 26 Wilkins Road, Toms River, Nj 08753
    Sold May 2026 · 5 bd · 3 ba · 2,800 sq ft
    $1,430,000

Recent closed sales in this home's community, per the MLS. Shown for context only, not a valuation.

Interior

Bedrooms
3
Bathrooms
1
Stories
1

Exterior & Parking

Lot Size
0.251 acres
Pool
Yes

Construction & Zoning

Year Built
1976
Architectural Style
Ranch Rambler
Building Description
1F 2207
Land Use
Single Family Residential
Zoning
R75
Property Class
Residential
Block / Lot
Block 444.02, Lot 7
County
Ocean

Community & HOA

Community
Shelter Cove

Sale History

Last Recorded Sale
$181,280
Sale Date
August 19, 2019
Deed Reference
Book 17596, Page 00123

Is this your home?

17 homes sold in Shelter Cove this past year, in about 16 days at 99% of asking.

No algorithm, not even Zillow's, can see your home's condition, upgrades, or the street-by-street reality of this market. Jason will personally review the data and send your true value within 24 hours. Free, no obligation, and owners use it to track their equity long before they ever sell.

We respect your privacy and never share your info.

Property details are sourced from New Jersey public tax and property records (NJ MOD-IV / NJGIN and public parcel data). Recent sale information courtesy of Shore Realty Exchange via the MLS. Information is deemed reliable but not guaranteed and should be independently verified.