POWERED BY THE GARRETT TEAM of NJ REALTY PROS | 732-580-4712

Home/Toms River Property Records/Reynolds Avenue/534 Reynolds Avenue
Aerial view of 534 Reynolds Avenue, Toms River, NJ with the parcel outlined

534 Reynolds Avenue

Toms River, NJResidential

4
Beds
3
Baths
2004
Year Built
0.6915 ac
Lot Size

Tax & Assessment

Total Assessed Value
$947,200
Land Value
$254,000
Improvement Value
$693,200
Annual Property Tax
$17,258
Property Class
Residential

Neighborhood

$320,900
Median home value
$67,094
Median household income
84%
Owner-occupied

Source: U.S. Census Bureau, American Community Survey (5-year), for this home's census tract.

Nearby Schools

  • Ocean Academy Charter School
    Lakewood
    1.2 mi
  • Christa Mcauliffe Middle School
    Middle School · Jackson
    1.7 mi
  • Oak Street Elem School
    Lakewood
    2.3 mi
  • Spruce Street Elementary School
    Elementary · Lakewood
    2.3 mi
  • Joseph A. Citta Elementary School
    Elementary · Toms River
    2.4 mi

Nearest public schools by distance. Source: NCES (U.S. Dept. of Education). Confirm attendance zones with the school district.

Homes for Sale in the Community

197 Benjamin Street, Toms River, Nj 08755For Sale
$1,750,000
197 Benjamin Street, Toms River, Nj 08755
5 bd · 3 ba · 4,300 sq ft

Recent Sales in Tallymawr

  • 723 Palmer Avenue, Toms River, Nj 08755
    Sold Mar 2026 · 4 bd · 4 ba · 3,252 sq ft
    $1,800,000
  • 449 Brentwood Avenue, Toms River, Nj 08755
    Sold Nov 2025 · 5 bd · 3 ba · 4,368 sq ft
    $1,900,000

Recent closed sales in this home's community, per the MLS. Shown for context only, not a valuation.

Interior

Bedrooms
4
Bathrooms
3
Stories
2
Basement
Yes

Exterior & Parking

Lot Size
0.6915 acres
Parking
Garage · 2 spaces

Construction & Zoning

Year Built
2004
Architectural Style
Contemporary
Building Description
2F2G 4253
Land Use
Single Family Residential
Zoning
R200
Property Class
Residential
Block / Lot
Block 13.05, Lot 17
County
Ocean

Sale History

Last Recorded Sale
$749,000
Sale Date
August 1, 2018
Deed Reference
Book 17203, Page 01687

Is this your home?

1339 homes sold in Toms River this past year, in about 42 days at 99% of asking.

No algorithm, not even Zillow's, can see your home's condition, upgrades, or the street-by-street reality of this market. Jason will personally review the data and send your true value within 24 hours. Free, no obligation, and owners use it to track their equity long before they ever sell.

We respect your privacy and never share your info.

Property details are sourced from New Jersey public tax and property records (NJ MOD-IV / NJGIN and public parcel data). Information is deemed reliable but not guaranteed and should be independently verified.